Saturday

Homeward (Part 2): The Inevitable Answer

The easiest answer to “Why are you homeschooling?” is:  because we think it’s the right choice for these children, at this time.  We do not think that homeschooling is the great panacea.  Indeed, it most certainly cannot be.  For if we wanted to totally eliminate bad influences, ensure only the highest quality of education, and provide the model for holiness and wisdom, it, sadly, would not be found within the walls of our home.  We are imperfect and quite aware of it.  I don’t know anyone or any place this side of heaven that could fit that bill.  And, if the product of a child’s academic aptitude or social awareness were the ultimate measure, I’m not sure how we could possibly choose between traditional school or homeschool at all—seeing clear successes and failures on both fronts.  There is no perfect educational environment or learning style that fits all children and ensures perfect results, homeschool and classrooms included.

My husband and I are products of both the private and public school systems, entirely.  Both of our mothers are teachers, by profession and by vocation.  My mother-in-law worked for decades in the public school system as a teacher and an administrator.  It has been years since she taught 4th graders, but we still get sweet notes or comments from peers who remember her as their “favorite teacher.”  I have every confidence that her excitement for education was the highest octane of fuel for my husband’s outstanding academic career.

My own mother’s professional life as a teacher in the classroom was short, postponed perpetually due to my birth and the arrival of my five siblings.  Among the six of us, I was the only one never homeschooled for a time, but none of us was homeschooled entirely.  My parents tried as best they could to be responsive to each child’s social and scholastic needs.  My mother’s proclivity for teaching and the seriousness with which she understood her vocation were driving forces in how she raised us.   Now, with her children grown, she gravitates toward the local public elementary school as a sometimes substitute teacher, still thrilled by the connections she helps make between children and learning.   For both my husband and myself, education was an integral focus and highly valued within both of our families.

Because neither of us was ever homeschooled ourselves, our draw to consider it for our children surprises many people who know us.  We are the parents on every field trip.  We are the happy volunteers who serve on committees, man the bake sale table, and watch the class for a teacher’s planning period.  We really like our traditional school, its familiar faces, and beloved teachers.

On the other hand, those who know us well, tend to see the hardwiring within us that makes this decision more understandable.  I take at face value those who say, “I could NEVER homeschool.”  I trust that there are folks out there who have honestly never conceived of the notion that homeschooling could be a choice for them, for any number of reasons.  Yet, my husband and I have always considered it.  Since the first day our first child went to kindergarten, we wondered if it was the right choice.  We continued to wonder this each year even as we signed the registration papers for the next school year.  Our decision hasn’t come with thunder and lightning strikes, forcing us to suddenly realize that what we’ve done all along is wrong and we must find a new path.  Instead, it has been a process of continual consideration and prayer, which has forged for us a clear stream into this present moment.


Timing is everything, so they say.  And the time feels right.  For years, we have offered up the possibility of homeschooling to our children and, for years, we have discussed the pros and cons with them.  Neither they nor we are uneducated in the details.  Still, each year, we chose for them to go to back to school—a school we love, by the way—because, well, there just wasn’t a strong reason to change the status quo.  The only real impetus to continually consider bringing them home was the constant draw our hearts felt toward the idea.  And, these many years later, the tug in the direction of home outweighs the pull toward traditional school.

No comments: